Labour should ditch triple-lock pensions promise, says OECD

Organisation’s experts say pledge puts pressure on UK public finances and ‘adds significant fiscal risks’

Labour should ditch the triple-lock pensions promise to help tackle the UK’s straitened public finances, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development has urged.

In its latest survey of the UK economy, the Paris-based club of industrialised nations added its voice to those calling for an end to the pledge, which uprates the state pension each year by whichever is the highest of wage growth, inflation or 2.5%.

In a special chapter on pensions policy, the OECD’s experts say the triple lock “puts upward pressure on public expenditure and adds significant fiscal risks by exposing public finances to supply shocks, thus requiring a timely reform” – though it warns that public support would have to be built for any change.

As Rachel Reeves prepares to leave the Treasury after two years as chancellor, the OECD was broadly positive about her record, saying Labour’s pro-growth agenda “provides a strong basis for a gradual recovery”.

But its 140-page assessment repeatedly returns to the need to repair the public finances in the years ahead.

“Modest growth, high public debt, high interest payments and increasing spending pressures from ageing, climate and defence are limiting fiscal space,” it says, adding that the plans pencilled in by Reeves at last year’s spending review “leave limited room for manoeuvre”.

Thinktanks including the Resolution Foundation and the Institute for Fiscal Studies have called for reforming the triple lock, which was introduced by the Conservative-Lib Dem coalition in 2010.

The independent Office for Budget Responsibility has also highlighted the triple lock as a risk to long-term fiscal sustainability, pointing out that it has cost three times as much as anticipated when introduced.

The OECD suggests the annual increase should instead be an average of earnings and inflation – an approach that it estimates could make savings worth 2% of GDP in the long term.

Other money-saving measures it recommends include a drive to improve the productivity of hospitals, with spending on this crucial part of the NHS high by international standards.

“There may be scope to improve the efficiency of hospital operations,” the report says. “Operational improvements could include better coordination of patient discharges, at the right time to the right location, especially as capacity is constrained in out-of-hospital care.”

With a new chancellor expected to be in post next week as Andy Burnham takes over as prime minister , the survey also cautions against raising tax rates.

“Tax reforms should prioritise strengthening efficiency and revenues rather than raising headline rates. The tax burden is already high, while the system remains complex and distortionary,” it says.

Responding to the report, the chancellor said: “ The OECD agrees that we have restored stability, putting the economy in a much stronger position than it was two years ago.”

Launched at a press conference in London on Wednesday, the OECD’s assessment came after Reeves used her final Mansion House speech in the City to defend the decisions she has made, saying she had “proven the doubters wrong”.